Recap: I drew a strip for Li’l Depressed Boy.com. Yesterday were the pencils, so, here’s the inks:

I normally wouldn’t put this much tone into the page if I knew that it was going to get colored. See, in black and white comics things like cross-hatching and zip tones are used to denote shading, plane changes, and to control composition. When someone colors a comic, however, a lot of that shading is done in color instead of black ink, so the inker doesn’t have to try to push those gray tones quite as much (there are, of course, exceptions).
I was planning on using a more “color friendly” composition for this, but, Shaughn (Li’l Depressed Boy’s creator, writer and colorist) was enjoying the inking work I’ve been doing lately. He wanted to try to bring some of that into this page, so he asked me to draw the pages the same way I would draw a black and white page. I think the results are a little mixed.
I think the inks are definitely a little easier and cleaner to look at, but I think the colors suffered a little bit… specifically in the zip toned areas. Since the strip is shown in really low resolution on the site (probably about 72 dpi), the zip tones sort of turn into this weird plaid thing. Also, the black wall in panel six I think looks good here because the black pushes the composition. I think in the colored version, however, it looks strange that there’s a black wall in the background. In any case, I think this is a good learning experience for me and Shaughn. Art is really experimentation… sometimes the experiments don’t work out quite the way you like.
Okay, personal critique time.
Things that I DON’T like about my inks:
1) There’s an odd shadow under LDB’s belt on the viewer’s right side that probably shouldn’t be there. For that matter, that jacket that’s next to him is a little abstract as well.
2) I wish I could’ve made panel three “Pop” a little more. It feels a little muddy in terms of tone. This is one of those areas where I sorta fell back on Shaughn to clean up my mess in color.
3) LDB’s left hand (viewer’s right hand) in panel six… It feels like it’s resting on the floor when it shouldn’t, thus “pulling” the entire floor up… ugh. It’s because I drew it at bent at the wrist, so it looks like he’s supporting weight onto it. ::sigh:: Little screw up I didn’t catch until too late. Something I’d have to fix if I showed this page to an editor.
Now to make myself feel better, things I LIKE about the inks:
1) LDB’s pants in panel 1. I like the way the dry brushing really pushed the texture.
2) The shot of the Moondance Diner is great. I feel that is one of the most successful “background” shots I’ve ever drawn.
3) Panel Five… All of it. I like that the straw disappears into her hair, I like her facial expression… I just think that’s a really nice panel, but I’ve always liked drawing faces.
4) The last panel is also nice… Mostly in that I don’t feel like I screwed up anything major.
So, those posters in the background… The best we’ve got so far is two. Maybe you’ll be able to read them better in the inks. I’ll post the answers tomorrow.